Well, apparently you haven't seen the studies that talk about the dangers of prolonged standing. Nor any of the studies or books done specifically related to guitar playing. Also Wikipedia is written by people like you and I and is in no way a reliable source of information for anything.
At any rate it's not all about the back (unless someone has back issues). Using classical technique incorporates many parts of the body, the legs, back, arms and like everything else with classical guitar technique there are trade offs. the idea is to balance the stress to different areas as to not over-stress any particular one. While standing will alleviate back issues (so will playing with guitar centered over the right leg instead of the left) it also causes most of the tension/stress to be taken by the hands and shoulders. I'm all for standing while playing flamenco or rock or other styles of music (mostly chord based styles) but with the radical stretches and stress that the classical repertoire requires of the right hand, standing is not only bad advice for beginners it's reckless. And if anyone were to take your 'expert opinion' and end up with carpal tunnel syndrome, could possibly open you up to liability, since you state these things claiming to be an 'expert' on the subject. And just an example of the absurdity of it, do you also recommend that race car drivers modify their cars so as to drive long races standing up, based on your research of studie that show sitting for prolonged periods of time is bad?
I'm not implying I play better than you or even know more about it all than you do but I do doubt very seriously that your ability and knowledge surpasses that of Andres Segovia, Narcisco Yepes, John Williams, Manuel Barjueco, Julian Bream, Francisco Tarrega, and so on and not one of them plays standing or advocates it. Nor do any of these folks
http://www.oberlin.edu/newserv/05sep/gu ... ntion.html.
Although Paul Galbraith, Stanley Yates, Antigoni Goni, Dominic Frasc do take a slightly different apporoack to holding the guitar, not one of them plays standing. As far as i can tell from your youtube, neither do you when playing pieces from the classical repotoire. From what I could see, other than your flamenco and jazz pieces (awesome stuff by the way), you play sitting with a FOOTSTOOL! And even if you do play classical standing (although not reflected in your youtube videos) I suggest trying this with a few Augustin Barrios peices (very demanding right hand stretches) and see how long that lasts.
Again I think standing is best for many musical styles but if I'm not going to argue the importance of standing while playing rock music on a classical guitar forum. Whether it's played on a Spanish guitar or not. But it's also worth mentioning that when referring to the 'classical' guitar, this refers more the the style in which it is played and the music chosen, as the actual name of the instrument is 'Spanish' guitar. Point being, if this forum were called Spanish guitar stylings, your argument may be more appropriate. The aggressive way you go about it wouldn't, nor would the belittling and backhanded insults. You stated (rudely) on another forum that you were going to give up this battle (and why one should feel the need to battle a point, I don't understand but to each his own). What happened to that idea? I mean, so people can actually have discussions about classical guitar technique and ways to improve on it. Rather than internet battles I'd expect to find on a sight for arrogant disc jockeys (sorry to anyone that deejays but if you've been on any of those sites you'll know what I mean).
I Don't think it's very cool to go on to every single post on this site regarding better ways to use a footstool (for those that aren't comfortable with supports, which are definitely a better option ergonimically to footstools) to attack, and berate people for doing it wrong. It's also is a little false to do so and then expect words like, well if it works for you then great, to smooth it over. Trolling forums and highjacking every attempt to have a discussion about better ways to use a footstool, is not only rude, it's against forum policy from what I understand. I could be wrong there, as I am new to the forum. Which leads me to another point. I joined this site to have intellectual discourse about classical guitar playing and technique, etc. And have since spent more time defending myself from a bully than anything else. A little ridiculous if you ask me.
Yes there are a lot of issues with back pain and people complain a lot about it and there are many threads (and even books) devoted to the theme, but if you look a little more you'll find there are just as many devoted to hand pain and leg pain. Again the idea is to find a more balanced approach and not to throw the baby out with the bathwater, Such as protecting against back pain at the risk of much greater problems. I've known people with such bad carpal tunnel they couldn't lift a glass and I'd venture to guess any one of them would have traded that for some minor back discomfort. As far as memory foam goes, just for the record it is working great for me and I mentioned because it keeps my leg from falling asleep or tingling (not as a solution to all discomfort). Why does it do this even though only my butt touches it? Because it allows better circulation! And guess what, it even helps with the back discomfort a bit. If you knew as much about anatomy as you claim to, you'd understand that the leg bone is connected to the thigh bone and so on and everything that happens in our bodies can have an effect on other parts of the body. Stress that starts at one muscle group has a way (and I'm not going to go into the specifics of how that works, you can search wikipedia for that one) of spreading to adjacent muscle groups and so on. So, even chewing gum helps me, because I am a teeth clencher. And guess what I feel the difference in my arms and hands when I chew gum.
Anyway I'm done with this argument, and would have never even given it my time in the first place if not for the fact that I had serious issues with my hands after a year or two of classical study becuase I was flipant about posture and the way I held the guitar. And just becuase one person got lucky and didn't get problems doesn't mean that some young kid (or other beginner taking your advice won't)... Oh and also because I despise bullying and thread highjacking regardless of how it's sugar coated by saying to each his own... thank you and have a good day sir.
