robert e wrote: ↑
Wed Mar 20, 2019 12:58 pm
I agree with Maniac [EDIT: and JW] that they are both playing it as written, but balancing the voices differently, for one thing. An enlightening listening exercise--thanks!
I am not sure if you folks are talking about the same part I was referring to. It is not a voice balance of notes but a different note being played in the melody. It sounds distinctly different (to me anyway). I don't play the piece but playing along by ear on my guitar, Williams plays the sequence as A-A-B-C-D-D-G, Park plays it as A-A-B-A-D-D-G.
I have since listened to 15 pros playing it and only found 3 (Russell, Moller, JiJi) who plays it like Park, the rest (Vandanyan, Hurwitz, Rojas, Yang, Fisk, Goni, Moretti, Romero ....) and the man himself the composer Barrios, plays it like Williams.
This is from Barrios's original recording
I'll try to google the score and point out the note I am referring to later.